Here is a short description of how the Best Paper Award Committee selects the awards.
Each Senior PC members could put forward a nomination from the papers they were responsible for. We had were six papers nominated by the SPCs as best paper candidates. Next, a best paper award committee was formed, consisting of six SPC and PC members, who did not have conflict of interest with the nominated papers, as well as the two PC chairs.
Each member of the best paper award committee independently reviewed all six papers and then recommended two best paper candidates from the six papers. Based on these reviews, discussion and voting was conducted among the members, to select both best paper and best student paper award.